CA Court Tosses Animal Rights Hunting Lawsuit

2019-11-08 | AKC Government Relations Department

A California Superior Court ruling has tossed a lawsuit brought by a group of animal rights organizations against the use of GPS collars and treeing switches on hunting dogs. The Sacramento Superior Court issued a final ruling Oct. 24, 2019, dismissing the lawsuit.

The animal rights groups included the Public Interest Coalition, Animal Legal Defense Fund and Friends of Animals. Their action challenged a December 2016 decision by the California Fish and Game Commission to remove prohibitions on global positioning systems (GPS) and treeing switches in dog collars for dogs used in hunting mammals. The suit claimed the Commission's changes did not meet the "common-sense" exemption for the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). In particular, the challenge said the Commission did not address the “significant impacts” that the use of the devices would cause.

While not formally weighing in on the case, American Kennel Club Government Relations Department was a part of a coalition of dog and hunting organizations that monitored the lawsuit.

While the Commission’s 2016 decision focused on hounds used in hunting big game that is typically treed, the animal rights lawsuit included generalized allegations that the use of dogs in hunting is “cruel, unethical, wasn’t fair chase and gave an unfair advantage to hunters”.

The suit also said that hunters are basically lazy and conspire with poachers to take game illegally, thus the use of GPS collars and treeing switches would enable these “conspirators” to poach on a scale that would cause significant environmental impacts.

Even though the suit was directed at the Fish and Game Commission, the California Attorney General’s office stepped in to defend the Commission’s ruling.  The court decision, focused on allegations of CEQA violations, disregarded the emotional and non-factual language that filled the suit. 

AKC GR is pleased that this ruling rejected the claims of the animal rights groups and we will continue to monitor this issue. 

Terms of Use The American Kennel Club, Inc. (AKC) owns and operates this website. By accessing and using this site, you agree to each of the terms and conditions set forth herein, our Privacy Policy, and agree to abide by the AKCs Bylaws, rules, regulations, procedures as set forth in the AKC Charter and Bylaws, rules, regulations, published policies and guidelines. Additional terms and conditions applicable to certain areas of this website or as to certain transactions are posted in those areas or in connection with a particular transaction, and together with these Terms of Use govern your use of those areas and/or transactions. AKC reserves the right to modify these Terms of Use at any time without prior notice. Your use of this site following any modification constitutes your agreement to be bound by the Terms of Use as modified. The last date these Terms of Use were revised is set forth below. You may use this website for lawful purposes only. You may not use this website for any purpose that is prohibited by law or regulations or to facilitate the violation of any law or regulation. PRIVACY POLICY Our Privacy Policy describes our practices concerning data that you provide or that we may collect about you through this site, and you consent to our use of data in compliance with the Privacy Policy. Sweepstakes, contest, and promotions may also have additional rules and eligibility requirements, such as age or geographic restrictions. You are responsible for complying with these rules and requirements.